D-backs and Hall of Fame Voting


Photography: Barry Gossage


As you may have heard by now, second baseman Roberto Alomar was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame on Wednesday, a deserving honor for a player who batted .300 with a .371 on-base percentage and played spectacular defense over 2,379 games in the Major Leagues.


Alomar was also, notably for us Arizonans, the first Hall of Famer player to ever suit up and play for the D-backs. He played 38 games for the D-backs in 2004, his final year in the big leagues.


I figured this would be a good opportunity to look at how former D-backs players have fared on ballots since 2004, the first year any former D-backs player would ever be eligible for Hall voting (Arizona began play in 1998, and a player must be retired for five seasons to be eligible).


The number next to the player’s name is the total vote count for him and the percentage of possible votes he received. Any player over 75 percent is elected to the Hall of Fame, while anyone under five percent falls off the ballot. This is for D-backs players only, so it wouldn’t count former coach Robin Yount, who is a Hall of Famer, or current coach Alan Trammel, who is still on the ballot.












Devon White – 0 – 0%

Bobby Witt – 0 – 0%



Todd Stottlemyre – 1 – 0.2%



Mark Grace – 22 – 4.1%

Matt Williams – 7 – 1.3%

Jay Bell – 2 – 0.4%

Dan Plesac – 0 – 0%



Roberto Alomar – 397 – 73.7%

Shane Reynolds – 0 – 0%



Roberto Alomar – 523 – 90.0%

Raul Mondesi – 0 – 0%

Carlos Baerga – 0 – 0%

Lenny Harris – 0 – 0%


Here are some of the eligible players who will come up on the ballot in future years:



Tony Womack

Jeff Fassero

Tim Worrell

Terry Mulholland

Rick Helling

Felix Rodriguez



Curt Schilling

Steve Finley

Bob Wickman

Shawn Green

Jeff Cirillo

Tony Batista

Mike Myers

Royce Clayton

Reggie Sanders

Damian Miller



Luis Gonzalez

Richie Sexson

Shawn Estes



Randy Johnson

Tom Gordon

Alan Embree

Tony Clark

One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s